6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes

If you’re looking for the best drugstore mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes, check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras under $11!

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes

Aside from my undying love for lipstick, if there’s one makeup product I’m obsessed with, it’s mascara!

Like a lot of people out there, my favorite facial feature is my eyes, and I love how a great mascara instantly draws attention to them and makes them stand out even more! And in my opinion, there’s nothing more beautiful than thick, long-looking lashes.

But like most of my makeup products, I’m extremely picky when it comes to my mascara. I want a mascara that lengthens, defines, adds volume, and curls my lashes, without clumping and smudging. That’s not too much to ask, right? 

Over the years I’ve tried out dozens of affordable mascaras and high end mascaras on the hunt for the best of the best, and honestly the best mascaras that have came out on top have always been drugstore mascaras. 

So for today’s post I’ve rounded up the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes with the top drugstore mascaras for adding length and definition to short lashes.

These best drugstore mascaras not only will make your lashes look long, lush, and beautiful, but they also are super affordable at under $11 each!

 

Check Out These Posts Next:

 

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes

*This post contains affiliate links. Thank you for supporting Kindly Unspoken Blog!

To make it easy for anyone reading this post, I’ve ranked and categorized the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes below, and included photo comparisons on how each mascara looks on my lashes. 

That said, every single drugstore mascara on this list is amazing and I would gladly recommend all 6 of these mascaras to anyone out there who is looking for a great mascara to add length, volume, and definition to their lashes.

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

If your lashes need a little help in the lengthening/strengthening department, I would also recommend checking out my posts on My Favorite Lash Serum and How to Apply Lash Serum.

Once I started using this lash serum (Get 15% Off with KINDLY15) , it was a total game changer in how my lashes looked and paired with the mascaras below, I truly look like I’m wearing falsies! 

 

6 Best Drugstore Mascaras Ranked by Favorite
  1. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
  2. Loreal Telescopic Carbon Black Mascara
  3. Loreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara
  4. Essence Lash Princess Sculpted Volume Mascara
  5. Physicians Formula 3-in-1 Lash Mixologist
  6. Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Mascara

 

Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara – Best Drugstore Mascara for Long, Feathery Lashes

If there’s one drugstore mascara on this list that you need to check out, it’s this one! The False Lash Effect Mascara from Essence has been my hands down favorite mascara for several years now, and it seriously makes you look like you’re wearing falsies or lash extensions.

It’s such an incredible mascara for lengthening, separating, curling, and adding volume, and I’m always shocked that it’s under $5. The formula is extremely buildable without clumping and I love how the wand can reach even the tiniest lashes. 

Buy on Amazon | Buy at Ulta

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Loreal Telescopic Carbon Black Mascara – Best Drugstore Mascara for Lengthening + Separating Lashes

Long before this became a Tiktok makeup sensation, this drugstore mascara has been my ride or die for 15+ years, and to date I haven’t been able to find a mascara out there that lengthens and separates better than this one.

The brush is perfectly shaped for coating every tiny lash on both top and bottom, and it can make even the shortest lashes out there look long and lush!

If you want a mascara that doesn’t disappoint, buy this one. 

Buy on Amazon | Buy at Ulta

 

Loreal Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara – Best Drugstore Mascara for Adding Length, Volume, & Curl

Another cult-favorite in the beauty world for several years now is this awesome mascara. It’s been one of my go-to’s for many years and I would definitely compare it to the Too Faced BTS Mascara (which is amazing).

It’s just an all-around awesome mascara and if you’re looking for something that does it all, this is it. It lengthens, adds volume, and curls the lashes, and is a truly buildable mascara for creating falsie-looking lashes.

Buy on AmazonBuy at Ulta

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Essence Lash Princess Sculpted Volume Mascara – Best Drugstore Mascara for Lengthening + Curling Straight Lashes

Another ride or die mascara I’ve had in my makeup collection for several years now is the Sculpted Volume Mascara from Essence.

Prior to using this lash serum, my lashes used to always be stick straight.  This mascara has always did an amazing job of lifting my lashes and giving them a beautiful curl, as well as lengthening and adding volume.

All that combined with the fact it’s only $4.99 makes it one of my all-time favorite drugstore mascaras!

Buy on AmazonBuy at Ulta

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Physicians Formula 3-in-1 Lash Mixologist – Best Drugstore Mascara for Lengthening + Strengthening Lashes

Everyone knows Physicians Formula for their unbeatable Butter Bronzer and awesome face products, but I’m here to tell you NOT to sleep on this amazing drugstore mascara.

This affordable two-sided mascara lengthens, adds volume, and conditions the lashes to keep them looking healthy and beautiful. The lengthen side wand does a great job of separating out every tiny lash, and the volume side wand makes your lashes look feathery, dramatic, and so pretty! 

This one is probably my favorite buildable mascara and I love that you are getting two wands for one low price. 

Buy on AmazonBuy at Target

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Mascara – Best Smudge-Proof Drugstore Mascara that Lengthens + Volumizes

Last but certainly not least on this list of the best drugstore mascaras, is this amazing smudge-proof mascara from Essence. I’ve only been using this mascara for around a month, but it’s quickly grown to be a favorite!

If you have allergies or eyes that water a lot and your mascara tends to smudge, I highly recommend this mascara. It is seriously smudge-proof, lasts all day, and is just as amazing as all the other Essence mascaras in lengthening, adding volume, and curling the lashes.

It is also surprisingly easy to remove and wipes off gently with warm water (which is unusual for most smudge-proof mascaras). 

Buy on AmazonBuy at Ulta

 

Bonus Mascara Recommendation:

Loreal Voluminous Lash Primer – Best Drugstore Mascara Primer

If you really want to give your lashes a boost, I HIGHLY recommend using this awesome and affordable drugstore mascara primer.

I’ve been using it for several years now and it is amazing for adding extra volume and length to my lashes and making my eyelashes look even more dramatic when wearing mascara.

I typically use it underneath my Loreal Telescopic Mascara, but it also works great with the other mascaras above. 

Buy on AmazonBuy at Ulta

6 Best Drugstore Mascaras with Photos

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Shop all the mascaras here
 
More Drugstore Makeup Recommendations

Hope you enjoyed today’s post on the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for Lengthening Lashes! Have you tried any of my recommended best drugstore mascaras? Which one is your favorite from the list? Let me know in the comments below! 

Thanks for stopping by! – Cara

 

Pin This Post

Looking for the best drugstore mascaras? Check out my list of the 6 Best Drugstore Mascaras for lengthening, curling, and adding volume to short lashes. These affordable drugstore mascaras are better than high end mascaras and cost less than $11 each! #drugstoremascaras #drugstoremakeup #mascara #bestmakeup

Leave a Comment

 

8 Comments

  1. Bernadette wrote:

    I could happily stay in the land of drugstore mascaras because there are that many affordable ones out there! Really, only benefit mascaras are worth the $$$. Maybelline is my go to affordable mascara brand. x

    http://www.themakeupaficionado.com

    Posted 12.12.20 Reply
    • Kindly Unspoken wrote:

      I completely agree! Plus with the quick expiration on mascaras, it’s not super cost effective to spend a ton on mascara. Which benefit mascara is your favorite? I’ve never tried any from them.

      Posted 12.13.20 Reply
  2. Nadine wrote:

    Lash paradise is my favorite. I love the purple Essence but hate the green. Weird, right? I love when you can find a few good drugstore mascaras!

    Posted 11.24.20 Reply
    • Kindly Unspoken wrote:

      I had stopped using Lash paradise for awhile but recently started again and it’s just SO good! And that’s so funny because I used to be the same way with the essence ones. I’ve always loved the purple but gave the green another chance and it actually makes my lashes look better than the purple one when I compared the two. But mascara is like any makeup product out there- wear what works best for you! šŸ™‚

      Posted 12.2.20 Reply
  3. Rebecca Jo Vincent wrote:

    I’m totally looking for the Panda Eyes. My eyes water so much every morning with allergies

    Posted 11.23.20 Reply
    • Kindly Unspoken wrote:

      I highly recommend it! I always wear it anytime I need to make sure my mascara doesn’t run.

      Posted 12.2.20 Reply